Compare property management software options for small landlords and learn when a full PM system is overkill, and when a communications-focused solution is the better choice.
If you're a small landlord or property manager, you've probably wondered: "Do I need full property management software, or is there a simpler solution?" The answer depends on what problems you're actually trying to solve. If your main challenge is responding to leads fast enough, a communications-focused solution might be better than full PM software.
This guide will help you understand your options, from comprehensive PM platforms to specialized tools that solve specific problems, like handling rental inquiries faster.
Small landlords (those with 1-50 units) face unique challenges:
The biggest pain point? Handling rental inquiries. It's time-consuming, requires constant availability, and directly impacts your bottom line. But is a full PM system the right solution?
Full PM platforms (like AppFolio, Buildium, or Rent Manager) typically include:
✅ Centralized: Everything in one place
✅ Comprehensive: Handles all aspects of property management
✅ Scalable: Grows with your portfolio
✅ Professional: Impresses investors and partners
❌ Expensive: $1-3 per unit per month (or more)
❌ Complex: Steep learning curve, lots of features you may not need
❌ Time-consuming setup: Can take weeks to configure properly
❌ Overkill for small portfolios: Many features go unused
AppFolio: Best for mid-size portfolios (50+ units). Strong accounting features.
Buildium: Good for smaller portfolios. User-friendly interface.
Rent Manager: Powerful but complex. Best for experienced property managers.
Cozy/Apartments.com: Good for very small landlords (1-5 units).
These tools solve one problem really well: handling rental inquiries and communication.
Instead of trying to do everything, they focus on:
✅ Simple: Easy to set up and use
✅ Focused: Solves the #1 pain point (lead handling)
✅ Fast ROI: See results immediately (more tours, faster responses)
✅ Low maintenance: Automation handles the work, you jump in when needed
✅ Scales with you: Works for solo operators to teams managing multiple properties
❌ Limited scope: Doesn't handle accounting, maintenance, etc.
❌ Requires other tools: You'll still need separate solutions for other workflows
Propel is an AI-first automation platform that automates prospect engagement end-to-end:
When it makes sense: You want automation-first lead management where AI does the work for you. You're losing leads because you can't respond fast enough, or you're spending too much time on inquiry responses. You prefer tools that work for you rather than requiring you to manage them daily.
You probably don't need full PM software if:
The cost and complexity often outweigh the benefits. You can manage with:
If inquiries are your biggest challenge, a communications-focused tool is more effective than a full PM system. You'll see faster results and spend less money.
Full PM systems require significant setup time and training. If you need something that works immediately, start with a focused solution.
If you're happy with your accounting (QuickBooks, spreadsheets) and maintenance (email, phone), don't replace them. Add tools that solve specific problems.
Propel is designed for real estate professionals (landlords, property managers, real estate agents) who:
What Propel does:
What Propel doesn't do:
Propel works alongside your existing tools:
This "best-of-breed" approach lets you choose the best tool for each job, rather than being locked into one platform.
Use this framework to decide what you need:
List your top 3-5 challenges:
Which pain points cost you the most money or time?
If inquiry handling is your #1 problem: → Start with a communications-focused tool like Propel
If you have multiple high-impact problems: → Consider full PM software, or combine specialized tools
If you're not sure: → Start with a focused solution for your biggest pain point, then add tools as needed
Many successful small landlords use a hybrid approach:
This gives you:
Sarah manages 15 units as a side business while working full-time.
Her challenges:
Her solution:
Results:
Book a demo to see how Propel handles inquiries automatically, without the complexity and cost of full PM software.
For many real estate professionals, full property management software is often overkill. If your main challenge is handling inquiries faster and converting more leads, an automation-first solution like Propel is more effective and requires less ongoing maintenance than a comprehensive PM platform.
Propel automates prospect engagement end-to-end, from instant responses to qualification, tour booking, and follow-ups, while building a pipeline that organizes itself. You jump in when needed, but the system handles the ongoing work automatically.
Start with the tool that solves your biggest problem. You can always add more tools later as your needs grow.
Learn more about Propel's approach to lead handling. See our getting started guide and learn how to automate rental inquiries from all sources. For a comparison with other tools, see our guide on Follow Up Boss vs Propel.
See how Propel can help you convert more inquiries and book more tours automatically.
Compare Follow Up Boss and Propel for real estate lead management. Learn the difference between AI-first automation and traditional CRM approaches.
Learn how to choose the right real estate lead software for your business, with comparison of automation capabilities, integration requirements, pricing models, and feature sets for 2025.
Use our free calculator to see how faster response times impact your conversion rates and revenue. Model different scenarios and see the ROI of responding within 5 minutes.